Flame Weapons

[Endoperez]

Exactly.

With hoof (1 attack), you get:
1 hoof
1 fire

With Sword of Swiftness (2 attacks), you get:
1 sword
2 fire

With Gloves of the Gladiator (4 attacks), you get:
1 gloves
4 fire

[triqui]

What about my question?

Does the physical damage from the weapon itself count as magic?

If a hoof with fire attacks a Black Servant, does the black servant gets its 75% ethereal "saving throw" versus the physical damage and eats the fire damage, or is the hoof as a whole considered a magical weapon?

[ano]

AFAIK, flaming weapons do not affect ethereal SC's with fire resistance, so probably only 6AP fire damage is magic. I did not make special tests but it always seemed to be so.