The thing is, that some people don't quite like the specific art type that that game features (like me), which leaves them staring at some really bad looking models. (otherwise, you have both style and "tech-abilities" to like [to like atleast one of them])
Though actually what really bothers me about WC3 is the gameplay, since its a game that bases itself on the idea that MicroManagement brings victory, and I don't really like to have to take part in the insane clickfest just to play a game.
I guess that's why I like TBS games, like Dominions
Also, DominionsFAN, HoMMIV is definitely not a popular game. I'll just say that 3DO didn't bankrupt for fun and leave it at that.
*cough*oneofthemostdisappointinggamesever*cough*ho pefulyubisoftslatestaddittionwillmakethingsbetter* cough*