.com.unity Forums
  The Official e-Store of Shrapnel Games

This Month's Specials

Raging Tiger- Save $9.00
winSPMBT: Main Battle Tank- Save $6.00

   







Go Back   .com.unity Forums > The Camo Workshop > WinSPMBT > TO&Es
Notices


 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
  #1  
Old February 17th, 2012, 04:55 PM

Pibwl Pibwl is offline
Captain
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Poland
Posts: 886
Thanks: 85
Thanked 241 Times in 174 Posts
Pibwl is on a distinguished road
Default Hungarian OOB 5.5

Less extensive suggestions, than for the Czech one.

002, 003 T-34/85 M1947 - "M1947" isn't original designation, possibly used by some modern sources, and is IMO redundant, since they are the only T-34s in the OOB.
It's worth to replace 5 AP with Sabot (standard Russian load of Sabot, in early T-34/85 at least).

I wrote in other place, that Soviet standard load was 36 HE, 19AP/Sabot - but 30 HE, 25 AP/Sabot should be OK as well. I've just found 30/25 in a Polish book, possibly from Polish 1962 manual. It might concern also Polish OOB, if 002 T-34/85 was changed there to 36 HE, 19 AP/Sabot. It's sure better for a tank game.

011-13 T-55AM - proper picture of AM with extra armour is 11150. According to Polish nTW-4/99 magazine, Hungary has T-55s with Czech Kladivo FCS (as also these photos show http://mhrfweb.makett.org/MHRF/index...mid=11&lang=en ) so they should have FC 25 and laser RF, like in the Czech OOB (now only FC 15, RF 6). Probably also SD should be doubled (8 tubes).

016 T-72M1 - starting date at 1/100 is doubtful - I guess, though it's hard to find sources, that T-72M1 were delivered to Hungary at the same time, as to other Warsaw Pact members - maybe a bit later, say 1/88, maybe 1/89. It would be little likely to buy these tanks in 2000, when they were definitely obsolete. nTW-4/99 magazine (info probably based upon Military Balance 1998/99) says, that Hungary has T-72M/M1 tanks.
Of course, if we make if available earlier, it should have earlier gun, so it might be split in two units. But I don't know, if the Hungarians bought new ammo, especially multi-charge Heat, which are quite rare designs.
FC is 25, while Soviet T-72A has FC 20 (which seems closer to truth for ordinary A/M1).

025 ISU-122 - the picture is in fact ISU-152 (thick barrel with a muzzle brake). Proper ISU-122 is 0089 (or 29047 or 11260). Ammo load should be only 30 - approx. half HE and AP, with no Heat (now 40).

026 SU-76M - standard Russian ammo load was 31 HE, 19 AP and 10 sabot (now: HE 20, AP 20, Heat 20).

030 BRDM-1 Shmel - better picture is 29057 (current one 11031 is 2P32 Falanga). They carried only 6 missiles (3 + 3 reloads - now: 8 - for all countries). Correct icon with 3 missiles is 2945. Starting date at 1/61 is very doubtful, since only in 8/60 it was commissioned in the USSR, and then started its production. Realistic date is some 1962-63.

033, 038 BRDM-2 Malutka - Malutka-P didn't replace ordinary Malutka from 1/100, but rather from the beginning it should be semi-automatic 9P133 Malutka-P (on photos from some Hungarian museum http://mhrfweb.makett.org/MHRF/index...mid=11&lang=en ). Ordinary Malutka on BRDM-2 (9P122 vehicle) was produced for a short time and mostly exported to Arab countries. In 2000, the Hungarians would have to be mad to buy obsolete Malutka-P system.

There should ba added BRDM-2 Konkurs, or rather Konkursz, as is locally spelled (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jBHlAdzqlKA at 1:58). I guess, from mid-80s.
May be instead of 418 BRDM-2 HOT

049 SA-4 Ganef - proper name 2K11 Krug. Withdrawn in 1997 (now: 12/100) [source Raport 9/2002 magazine]

050 SA-6 Gainful - there could be created modernized SA-6 (properly 2K12 Kub) from 2003 - electronics was improved in Poland (less prone to jamming, better radar range) and part of fire control vehicles were fitted with TI.

052 BRDM-1 - very rarely (if at all) armed with DShK MG - normal armament was just one 7.62mm AAMG (for all countries).

#058 D-422 FUG - FUG was produced from 1963, commissioned in 1964 (now 1/66) [nTW3/98].

065 BMP-1 - as I wrote in other place, BMP-1 don't carry semi-automatically guided Malutka-P, just ordinary Malutka (Malutka-P can be fired in manual mode, without improved accuracy). I don't know, if the Hungarians modified guns in BMP-1.

066 PSzH-IV (light APC) - correct picture is 23484. I don't think if vision 30 is justified - it had ordinary active night sights.

67 Heavy Truck - better picture, and fit to icon with long nose, is 11067 (similar to Hungarian Csepel http://mhrfweb.makett.org/MHRF/index...mid=11&lang=en BTW - current one is typically Polish Star 660)

68 B10 Recoilless - 1/50 is impossible, since it was accepted by the Soviets in 1954. Realistic date is 1/55 (as in Poland)

72 Malutka ATGM - it is doubtful, if Malutka team carried also RPG-7 with rockets, apart from 18-kg missiles.

(in fact, Russian sources suggest, that 3-men crew carried only a guidance device and 2 missiles, but it would decrease playability I'm afraid...)

76 75mm AT-Gun - proper pic of PAK-40 is 23008 - current one is French mle.97 on PAK-38 chassis (what was its name?..)

77 45mm AT-Gun - proper pic of Soviet 45mm is eg. 29422. Better (smaller) icon is 54 or 55

85 100mm T-12 ATG - probably it should end later (now 12/89). We have another unit #550 after this date, with Kastet missiles, but I guess, that not every gun has missiles (I don't know if they are used in Hungary at all, BTW)

91 122mm Field Gun - a cosmetic change, but better icon is 59 (shorter howitzer barrel)

Weapon 112 122mm obr38 has too much range 209 - correct is 202 (Russian oob #112 122mm M-30 FH)

92 122mm Field Gun - I haven't found info, if the Hungarians had these guns. List of Hungarian armament in nTW 4/1999 doesn't list D-30, only 230 of M.38 howitzers (info probably based upon Military Balance 98/99)

98 Malutka-2 ATGM - as I wrote in other place, Malutka-2 was a Russian recent export proposal with twin Heat, not semi-automatic Malutka-P for SP-launchers. This unit should be in fact ordinary Malutka ATGM, with normal #145 Malutka. Same comment on RPG-7, as #72

99 85mm AT-Gun - 162 guns still listed in 1999 (now ending date 78)

Regards
Michal
Reply With Quote
 

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:31 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©1999 - 2024, Shrapnel Games, Inc. - All Rights Reserved.