Enemy Dominion

[oldbone]

Does positive enemy dominion help you? (in vanilla and/or CBM)

I read some posts that suggested only Growth (if they have it) would affect you when an enemy dom spreads to your lands (the other positive effects would not). But, in both vanilla and CBM, I see the positive icons for luck, order, etc in the gui!

Can someone confirm what happens when an enemy dom spreads into your lands?

Thanks in advance.

[bbz]

You don't get any positive effects from enemy dominion so if the scales of someone is 0rder 3 you don't get anything out of it but if you used Turmoil 3 and the enemy dominion takes over your dominion then you will get neutral order scale. I think only the population increase effect from growth works. A good idea (only temporal though) is to get only 1 candle on your province if it has been previously affected by enemy dominion in that case you will benefit from all the effects still left on that(until they adjust to your scales configuration). I think negative effects are in effect all the time but I am not really sure about that one.

[Corinthian]

Negative scales work no mater the owner of the scales. But of positive enemy scales, only growth works. And then only the pop growth, not the money. Unclear weather you get extra supplies.

There is a trick you can use though if you have priests. Enemy scales will count as your scales if you have your dominion in the province. So if your dominion takes over a province with great scales from enemy dominion and you normally have bad scales, then those great scales will last for a while and you will benefit from them until your real scales manifest. If you are bored you can trigger this effect by preaching in contested provinces. Allow the enemy dominion to improve the scales and when the are maxed you preach until its your dominion again. The good scales last for a while and you can thus benefit from them. If you have neutral scales the bonus scales gained this way will decay much slower.

[brxbrx]

in my own experience, I've used enemy luck scales to boost my cross breedings

[thejeff]

It's a little more complicated than that, I think.
Scales have some effects whoever owns them.
The in-battle effects of heat/cold, magic/drain are always in effect.
Enemy luck supposedly works as misfortune for generating events.
I'd assume spells that have different effects based on scales work on the actual scale, with no concern for whose dominion.

[PyroStock]

Originally Posted by thejeff

Enemy luck supposedly works as misfortune for generating events.

Perhaps for the % odds for +good/bad event, but not for the requirements of certain events. Recently, I had Misfortune1 Dominion yet had 1 province with Luck3 from enemy dominion. That province then received the 3000 gold + item + fire rubies event (which according to the dom3 event list is for Luck3 scales only). 3.26 & no mods. By the same token, I've never had barbarian/knight attacks in enemy luck dominion.

[bbz]

did you have 1 white candle of your dominion in that province or was it only black candles in it? I myself often get misfortune 2 and as one of my neighbours in a recent game had luck 3 I got 2 times 1500 gold event in 4 turns or so. But I think that is because of neutral luck.

[PyroStock]

Originally Posted by bbz

did you have 1 white candle of your dominion in that province or was it only black candles in it? I myself often get misfortune 2 and as one of my neighbours in a recent game had luck 3 I got 2 times 1500 gold event in 4 turns or so. But I think that is because of neutral luck.

2 black candles and the turn before was 3 black candles.

[Baalz]

Originally Posted by PyroStock

2 black candles and the turn before was 3 black candles.

Luck is a bit odd in that like growth you get a partial benefit from enemy dominion. The chance of good vs bad events is reversed (enemy luck dominion increases your chances of bad events) but the events that are unlocked correspond to the actual scales. So, luck-3 scales unlock some nice events. The thing to keep in mind though is other scales can unlock some pretty nasty events and strong enemy luck will make them much more likely to occur. Enemy luck-3/death-3 for instance will give you a lot of high pop killing events while they don't get that many. Luck/drain will give you that horrible "magic is fading" gem loss event. Luck/turmoil will give you a lot of indie attacks and compound things by giving you even more events. There's probably some bad stuff unlocked by sloth scales but I don't remember off the top of my head.

[bbz]

It could be a bug, though occuring 3 times its a bit strange.