That's the reason why I asked for the input of others, since he seems to be the only one to see impossibilities where there is none.
Quote:
Now we have a capitol from one of the players "uncontested".
|
Yes, so what is the problem exactly if no one controls the capital province ?
Quote:
More problems: it _IS_ perfectly possible to produce an infinite battle, even with reinforcements. Several SC builds can be done that they cannot die in 50 turns. That will, still, stale the game forever.
|
. That's the very reason I also suggested a fatigue mechanism for battle that last months, as a balance mechanism...
Also, you seem to forget that Dominions is not made from one single province but a lot of them. The war around would go on, even if 3 or 4 provinces are blocked.
Quote:
The whole "no need to sleeep item" is a complete non-sense.
|
Sigh... as is magic or in the most part all fantasy or science fiction games. I mean, gods walking the earth ? battles that are always fought during a single day in daylight ? If you are to remove all that doesn't make sense, you are going to remove just everything. It's to the devs to decide whether it make sense or not.
As far as I know, it might make sense to them that all troops fight in a single day in daylight in a month and all attackers rout at 5 pm and troops that can't rout die at 8 pm.
Who do you think you are ? All those point are for the game creators to decide, not you ! As far as I know, it's not written "johan osterman" nor "Kristoffer O" in your name tag. You simply do not know whether the solution I propose is whatever you call it, because it's not your decision, and AFAIK, it's not anything you (or I) can know about...
Quote:
In short, it sucks. I'm sorry if i burst your bubble, but the idea you thougth was so awesome, is not so awesome.
|
Again, I don't care if you think it sucks. I don't care about it being awesome. I don't care if it's complicated. The only think I'm interested in is whether it works, or not.
Since you seem bent on the idea that it doesn't, and I think the opposite, I asked for other people to point out which one is right.
Sad to see that only a few care ! Well, of course, after a page of discussion, I would also be reluctant to join and write some more...