GrudgeBringer,
public lists of "honourable" and "dishonourable" players have been explicitly forbidden. One is not a "dishonourable player", also, if he breaks an agreement in a roleplaying environment. Of course you can keep your private one ^^ but turning the thread into a trial of "arguments" about pacts breaking seems wrong to me.
-
I agree that if you want a treaty to be respected, you should post it (with your counterpart's agreement) on the forum. Otherwise it's a "private matter" you can use for nasty surprises on enemies
but not so binding of course, so don't come crying
For me, I'll
almost surely keep all my agreements, but just because it's in the character of my nation.
Not of course if I perceive serious threats from one's excessive gaining of power.