[Norfleet]

Well, that depends on what you mean by "wasn't the case". If you lost 37 out of 38, that looks like you received a severe beating, but managed to barely win. It might not look very much like a win as a result.

On the other hand, sometimes battle replays have little or no relationship to the battle which is actually displayed. This is a bug that has been known to occur from time to time, particularly in older Versions. It seems to have become more prevalent even in single player with 2.08.